Database
 

Thresholds Database > Lake eutrophication, River Bure, England

Certainty of shift: Demonstrated
Location: Europe, England, Norfolk Broadland, River Bure, Cockshoot Broad
System Type: Social-Ecological
Regime Shift Category: 4a
Ecosystem Type
Lake
Spatial Scale
Landscape/Local
Type of Resource Use
Conservation
Number of Possible Regimes
2
Ecosystem Service
Recreation, ecotourism
Time Scale of Change
Months
Resource Users
 
Reversibility of Shift
Alternating

Background

Alternate Regimes

1. Clear water, submerged macrophytes, abundant fish, few Daphnia

2. Eutrophic, phytoplankton, few fish, abundant Daphnia

Fast or Dependent Variable(s)
Fish and plant species composition, level of oxygen in the water
Slow or Independent Variable(s)
Phosphorus and nitrogen in sediments
Disturbance or Threshold Trigger(s)
Nutrients from sewage effluent
External / Internal Trigger
External

Mechanism

High phosphorus and nitrogen input from sewage increased the density of phytoplankton and zooplankton and turbidity of the water. The amount of dissolved oxygen decreased with an associated loss of benthic fish species and macro-invertebrate prey species. There is a cyclic shift between the alternate states.

Management Decisions in Each Regime

State 2: Cockshoot Broad (3.3ha. x 1m. deep) was isolated from sewage-effluent in 1982 and 70cm of sediment was pumped out. Total phosphorus concentrations fell quickly and dense macrophytic vegetation became re-established in one part of the Broad. In one area, the macrophyte population collapsed after 8 years of stable high biomass and remained low for two years. Fish were removed and the plants recovered, but conditions are still cyclic.

Contact
Jacqui Meyers

Email
jacqui.meyers@csiro.au

CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems,
PO Box 284,
Canberra ACT 2601

Keywords
Pollution, biomanipulation, empirical data, eutrophication

References

Moss, B., J. Stansfield, K. Irvine, M. Perrow, and G. Phillips. 1996. Progressive Restoration of a Shallow Lake: a 12-Year Experiment in Isolation, Sediment Removal and Biomanipulation. Journal of Applied Ecology 33, no. 1: 71-86. (E)